Friday, 6 February 2015

Taking Appearance Minutes and Quality of Performance into Account When Calculating Footballers Salaries.

Do footballers deserve their huge salaries even when they are not appearing on the pitch?

Let's look at some randomly selected Man Utd players and see how much they have earned for every minute of football they have played so far this season.

Rooney  - £4319
Van Persie - £3482
Herrera - £2936
Young - £2667
Rafael - £2453
Fellaini - £2227
Mata - £2122
Januzaj - £2057
Evans - £2023
Smalling - £1780
Carrick  - £1747
Shaw - £1560
Valencia - £1228
Jones - £1112
De Gea - £870

Wow!  For every minute Wayne Rooney is doing his job he gets paid £4,319!
But ignoring that, look at three of United's bottom 5 earners - Carrick, Valencia and De Gea.  United's best players are the lowest earners simply because they've played more minutes.  Look at Rafael, he's done nothing this season but he's up there in the top 5.

Some could argue United have been worth their money this season; but what about fans of Aston Villa, for example?  One of the most appalling teams ever to disgrace the Premier League, here are some randomly selected Aston Villa players.

nathan Baker420
ron vlaar647
Jores Okore471
Ciaran Clark303
Leandro Bacuna2022
Tom Cleverley436
Ashley Westwood265
Fabian Delph664
Andrea Weimann410
Gabriel Agbonlahor698
Darren Bent20000
Cristian Benteke618

Holy shit - Darren Bent has earned £20,000 for every minute of football he has played this season.  Bacuna has earned more than Carrick, more than Shaw, more than Valencia, more than Jones, and more than twice that of De Gea, and he's been SHIT!
The other players are earning a lot less than United's in general, as one would expect, but are they worth the amount they get paid?  Should Benteke get £618 per minute even though his performances have been low in quality?

I propose footballers should get a basic salary and then bonuses based on appearance and quality of appearance.

And that basic salary should be £25,000 a year - enough on which to live.  But if you ain't playing and you ain't playing in a manner that deserves recompense, then you ain't getting any more.

Appearance bonuses can be linked to what a player might demand for a weekly wage.
Assuming that a footballer could play up to 50 games a season, players would earn the following per minute:

Rooney - 3467
Van Persie - 2889
Herrera - 924
Young - 1364
Rafael  - 693
Fellaini - 924
Mata - 1502
Januzaj - 520
Evans - 751
Smalling - 693
Carrick - 924
Shaw - 578
Valencia - 809
Jones - 578
De Gea - 867

Ignoring player performance, here's what the United players have earned so far, this year, on the new appearance bonus system.

Basic Salary +

Rooney - 5778922
Van Persie - 4977556
Mata - 2208267
De Gea - 1794000
Young - 1448096
Valencia - 1106560
Carrick - 1015964
Fellaini - 796871
Jones - 623422
Herrera - 604587
Evans - 579107
Smalling - 560907
Shaw - 444311
Rafael - 406987
januzaj - 273000

Some of these salaries are still huge but you can immediately see that those players who have played more games have jumped closer to the top whilst players like Rafael have plummeted to the bottom.

But what about taking into account quality of performance too?

Based on performance (using performance statistics) here's what United's players should have earned so far this year.

Rooney - 7763034
Van Persie - 6786067
Mata - 2186184
De Gea  - 1584700
Valencia - 947953
Young - 873685
Carrick  - 650217
Fellaini - 594997
Jones - 324180
Herrera - 300278
Evans - 229712
Smalling - 205666
Rafael - 120739
Januzaj - 34580

As you can see - the best players are still earning the big bucks, but those who are not playing or under-performing are taking a decent hit in their wages - they're still big earners but it's less grotesque than it used to be when they were getting paid for either not doing their jobs or not doing their jobs well.

But what about Aston Villa.  After a miserable season, what do their players deserve from their performances?
nathan Baker9694
ron vlaar68735
Jores Okore73791
Ciaran Clark96864
Leandro Bacuna2571
Tom Cleverley305252
Ashley Westwood140344
Fabian Delph159083
Andrea Weimann323060
Gabriel Agbonlahor618735
Darren Bent0
Cristian Benteke141353

Look at that!  Bent has nought but a basic salary.  Bacuna has earned £2,571 in total whereas before he was earning almost that a minute.  Under the new system, he has earned 1% of what he would have earned on his current salary.  Unfortunate for him, but that's what you get when you're a bit shit and don't deserve your vast fortune.

Some players have done quite well out of the new pay system but not many.  Here is a list of percentages of pay under the new system compared to current salary.

Van persie113
De Gea088

As you can see, Rooney and Van Persie have earned more than they would have done.  De Gea and Mata are doing pretty well too.  But all the other players have lost money, whether due to lack of appearances or lack of quality in performance.

And Aston Villa?  Oh dear - Only Guzan emerges with any credit.

nathan Baker004
ron vlaar011
Jores Okore015
Ciaran Clark027
Leandro Bacuna001
Tom Cleverley042
Ashley Westwood039
Fabian Delph022
Andrea Weimann054
Gabriel Agbonlahor052
Darren Bent000
Cristian Benteke020

No comments:

Post a Comment